This paper analyzes the large sample behavior of the seasonal unit
root tests of Dickey, Hasza, and Fuller (1984, Journal of the American Statistical
Association 79, 355–367) when applied to a series that
admits a unit root at the zero but not seasonal spectral frequencies.
We show that in such cases the Dickey et al. statistics have
nondegenerate limiting distributions. Consequently, there is a nonzero
probability that, taken in isolation, they will lead the applied
researcher to accept the seasonal unit root null hypothesis and hence,
incorrectly, take seasonal differences of the series, even
asymptotically. The same conclusion holds if the process displays unit
root behavior at any of the zero and/or seasonal frequencies. Our
results therefore prove a conjecture made on the basis of Monte Carlo
simulation evidence, in Ghysels, Lee, and Noh (1994, Journal of Econometrics 62,
415–442) that the tests of Dickey et al., unlike those of
Hylleberg, Engle, Granger, and Yoo (1990,
Journal of Econometrics 44, 215–238), are unable to
separate between unit roots at the zero and seasonal frequencies.I thank Peter Burridge, Bruce Hansen, and three
anonymous referees for helpful comments on earlier drafts of this
paper.