Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-dh8gc Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-14T22:04:23.690Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Computers and the Subversion of British History

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  10 January 2014

R. J. Morris
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The influence of computer usage upon the landscape of British history has been subtle and often profound. This influence has been one of several historiographical and cultural trends which have changed the nature and scope of “history.” The declining importance of the so-called grand narratives of national and class histories, and the fragmentation and loss of cultural authority of scholarly history in the face of increasingly diffuse popular and political uses of “history,” cannot be separated from the impact of the new technologies. The coherence and accessibility of history is not only challenged by the postmodernist questioning of the very validity of the search for authoritative coherence and by the philosophical assertion of the self-sufficiency of the text as a basis for analysis and explanation. This coherence and accessibility is also being challenged by the increasing importance of information technology in historical research and teaching. The scholarly presentation of computer usage by historians has tended to emphasize technical and methodological aspects. Important as these are, this has tended to conceal the major philosophical issues raised by such computer usage.

There is then a double challenge to historical practice as it has been developed over the hundred years or so since Tout, Firth, and others established a modern institutional structure toward the end of the nineteenth century. The irony of the conjunction of the postmodern cultural and philosophical challenges and the computer user's technologically based challenge is not perhaps so surprising when it is considered that what the computer user is doing is creating metadata from data/sources/texts and producing metanarratives from that metadata.

Type
Research Article
Information
Journal of British Studies , Volume 34 , Issue 4 , October 1995 , pp. 503 - 528
Copyright
Copyright © North American Conference of British Studies 1995

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Stone, Lawrence, “History and Post Modernism,” Past and Present, no. 131 (May 1991), pp. 217–18Google Scholar; Joyce, Patrick and Kelly, Catriona, “History and Post Modernism,” Past and Present, no. 133 (November 1991), pp. 204–13Google Scholar, also Stone, L. and Spiegel, Gabrielle, “History and Post Modernism,” Past and Present, no. 135 (May 1992), pp. 189–208Google Scholar.

2 Denley, Peter and Hopkin, Deian, eds., History and Computing (Manchester, 1987)Google Scholar; Denley, Peter, Fogelvik, Stefan, and Harvey, Charles, eds., History and Computing II (Manchester, 1989)Google Scholar; Best, Heinrich, Mochmann, Ekkehard, and Thaller, Manfred, eds., Computers in the Humanities and the Social Sciences (Munich, 1991)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; L'ordinateur et le métier d'historien, Maison des Pays Ibériques (Bordeaux, 1990)Google Scholar; Smets, Joseph, ed., Histoire et informatique (Montpellier, 1992)Google Scholar. The journal History and Computing is now published by Edinburgh University Press, 22 George Square, Edinburgh EH8 9LF. Membership details of the Association for History and Computing are available from A. G. Schijvenaars via post, Computer en Letteren, Achter de Dom 22–24, NL 3512 JP Utrecht, Netherlands, or electronic mail, .

3 Slee, Peter R. H., Learning and a Liberal Education: The Study of Modern History in the Universities of Oxford, Cambridge and Manchester, 1800–1914 (Manchester, 1986), pp. 122–52Google Scholar.

4 Vernon, James, “Who's Afraid of the ‘Linguistic Turn’? The Politics of Social History and Its Discontents,” Social History 19 (1994): 81–97CrossRefGoogle Scholar; White, Hayden, Metahistory: The Historical Imagination in Nineteenth Century Europe (Baltimore, 1973)Google Scholar, and Tropics of Discourse (Baltimore, 1978), pp. 52–75Google Scholar; Lyotard, Jean Francois, The Post Modern Condition: A Report on Knowledge (Manchester, 1984)Google Scholar, shows considerable fascination with the impact of information technology on postmodern culture.

5 Fogel, R. W. and Engerman, Stanley L., Time on the Cross: The Economics of American Negro Slavery (London, 1974)Google Scholar; Hershberg, Theodore, ed., Philadelphia: Work, Space, Family and Group Experience in the 19th Century (Oxford, 1981)Google Scholar; Anderson, Michael, Family Structure in Nineteenth Century Lancashire (Cambridge, 1971)Google Scholar.

6 Harvey, Charles and Press, Jon, “Relational Data Analysis: Value, Concepts and Methods,” History and Computing 4 (1992): 98–109Google Scholar.

7 This much-loved package (Statistical Package for the Social Sciences) has run through many versions since historians began using it in the 1970s. Its current versions run on most microcomputer operating systems as well as mainframe environments.

8 Palmer, J. J. N., “Computerising Domesday Book,” Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 1 (1986): 279–89CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Slater, George, “The Hull Domesday Textbase: A Programmer's View,” University Computing 10 (1988): 2–8Google Scholar; Palmer, J. J. N., “The Hull Domesday Database Project,” Humanistiske Data 2 (1987): 4–23Google Scholar.

9 Adman, Peter, “Micro-MIST,” in Denley, and Hopkin, , eds. (n. 2 above), pp. 266–70Google Scholar; Adman, Peter, Baskerville, Stephen, and Beedham, Katherine, “Computer Assisted Record Linkage,” History and Computing 4 (1992): 2–15Google Scholar.

10 For details of the English version, see History and Computing, vol. 5, no. 3 (1992)Google Scholar; Woollard, Matthew and Denley, Peter, Source Oriented Data Processing for Historians: A Tutorial for Kleio, Halbgraue Reihe zur Historischen Fachinformatik, Band A 23 (Göttingen, 1993)Google Scholar; Jaritz, Gerhard, Images: A Primer of Computer-Supported Analysis with Kleio IAS, Halbgraue Reihe zur Historischen Fachinformatik, Band A22 (Göttingen, 1993)Google Scholar; Smets, Josef, Créer une base de données avec Kleio, Halbgraue Reihe zur Historischen Fachinformatik, Band 7 (Göttingen, 1990)Google Scholar; its previous versions had been in Latin, then German. Thaller, Manfred, Kleio: A Database System, Halbgraue Reihe zur Historischen Fachinformatik, Band 11 (Göttingen, 1993)Google Scholar.

11 Wrigley, E. A., ed., An Introduction to English Historical Demography (London, 1966)Google Scholar; Wrigley, E. A., Identifying People in the Past (London, 1973)Google Scholar, and Nineteenth-Century Society (Cambridge, 1972)Google Scholar.

12 McQueen, C. M. Sperberg and Burnard, Lou, Guidelines for the Encoding and Interchange of Machine Readable Texts (Chicago and Oxford, 1990)Google Scholar, and later versions; for a critique and defense, see Sampson, G. Geoffrey, “Writing within Bounds,” Times Literary Supplement 17, no. 4646 (April 1992), p. 14Google Scholar, and letters in editions dated May 8 and 22.

13 Phillips, John A., “Achieving a Critical Mass while Avoiding an Explosion: Letter-Cluster Sampling and Nominal Record Linkage,” Journal of Interdisciplinary History 9 (1979): 493–508CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

14 Nenadic, StanMorris, R. J., Smyth, James, and Rainger, Chris, “Record Linkage and the Small Family Firm: Edinburgh, 1861–1891,” Bulletin of the John Rylands Library of Manchester 74 (1992): 169–96CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

15 van Horik, René and Doorn, Peter, guest eds., “Scanning and OCR Special Issue,” History and Computing, vol. 5 (1993)Google Scholar; van Horik, René, “Optical Character Recognition and Historical Documents: Some Programs Reviewed,” History and Computing 4 (1992): 211–20Google Scholar, and Optical Character Recognition in the Historical Discipline: Proceedings of an International Workgroup Organized by Netherlands Historical Data Archive, Max-Planck-Institut für Geschichte, Halbgraue Reihe zur historischen Fachinformatik, Band 18 (Göttingen, 1993)Google Scholar.

16 Friedman, John B., “Cluster Analysis and the Manuscript Chronology of William du Stiphel, a Fourteenth Century Durham Scribe,” History and Computing 4 (1992): 75–97Google Scholar; Wilson, C. L. and Blue, J. L., “Neural Network Methods Applied to Character Recognition,” Social Science Computer Review 10 (1992): 173–95CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

17 Fogelvik, Stefan, Rotemansarkivet, datorn och användaren, Studier och Handlingar Rörande Stockholms Historia 6 (1989): 13–28Google Scholar; Fogelvik, Stefan, “The Archive at Your Desk: A New Laboratory,” in Standardisation et échange des bases de données historiques, ed. Genet, Jean Philippe (Paris, 1988), pp. 23–32Google Scholar.

18 Southall, Humphrey, “Mapping the Life Path: Creating and Analyzing Individual Histories as Sequences of Events, Using Early 19th Century Trades Union Records,” in L'ordinateur et le métier d'historien (Bordeaux: Maison des Pays Ibériques, 1990), pp. 161–69Google Scholar.

19 Mitchell, J. C. and Cornford, J., “The Political Demography of Cambridge, 1832–68,” Albion 9 (1977): 242–72CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

20 Phillips, John A. and Wetherell, Charles, “Probability and Political Behaviour: A Case Study of the Municipal Corporations Act of 1835,” History and Computing 5, no. 3 (1993): 135–53Google Scholar.

21 Hahn, Harley and Stout, Rick, The Internet: Complete Reference (Berkeley, 1994)Google Scholar; Gilbert, David and Southall, Humphrey, “Data Glasnost: A User-Friendly System for Access to Research Databases across Wide-Area Networks,” History and Computing 3(1991): 119–28Google Scholar.

22 On Line Public Access Catalogs are now available by way of the Internet for an increasing number of libraries. Those consulted recently range from the National Library of Scotland to the Library of Congress.

23 Bath Information and Data Service is based at the University of Bath in the United Kingdom and covers science, social science, and arts and humanities citation indexes. It is available to individuals within subscribing institutions for research and teaching purposes.

24 Oakley, Howard, “Highway Code,” Macuser 4 (February 1994): 62–67Google Scholar.

25 See Doorn, Peter, Kluts, Céleste, and Leenarts, Ellen, eds., “Data Computers and the Past,” in Cahier Vereniging voor Geschiedenis en Informatica (Hilversum, 1992), vol. 5Google Scholar, for a description of several such projects, notably Gonzáles, P., “Computerisation for the ‘Archivo General de Indias,’” pp. 52–67Google Scholar, which looks forward to disk-based means of dissemination.

26 This reduction has been taken further by introduction of PowerPC, although the intending user should check the potential of these new machines and the software based emulation with care. In one recent example of a powerful emulator based on a desktop Macintosh hardware platform, the maths coprocessor operated only at the level of a 286 DOS machine.

27 Borodkin, Leonid I. and Levermann, Wolfgang, eds., History and Computing in Eastern Europe, Max-Planck-Institut für Geschichte, Halbgraue Reihe zur historischen Fachinformatik, Band 21 (Göttingen, 1993)Google Scholar.

28 Morris, R. J., “The Historian at Belshazzar's Feast: A Data Archive for the Year 2001,” in Doorn, Kluts, and Leenarts, eds. (n. 25 above), pp. 42–51Google Scholar; for the most recent catalog oriented toward British and European material, see Shürer, K. and Anderson, S. J., with the assistance of Duncan, J. A., A Guide to Historical Data Files in Machine Readable Form (London, 1992)Google Scholar. This was published for the Association for History and Computing and can be obtained from the History Data Unit, Social Science Data Archive, University of Essex, Colchester CO4 3SQ.

29 Fogel, Robert W., Railroads and American Economic Growth (Baltimore, 1964)Google Scholar.

30 Hawke, G. R., Railways and Economic Growth in England and Wales, 1840–1870 (Oxford, 1970)Google Scholar.

31 Crafts, N. F. R., British Economic Growth during the Industrial Revolution (Oxford, 1985)Google Scholar; Wrigley, E. A. and Scholfield, R. S., The Population History of England, 1541–1871 (London, 1981)Google Scholar.

32 ó Gráda, Cormac, Ireland Before and After the Famine: Explorations in Economic History, 1800–1925 (Manchester, 1988), pp. 78–127Google Scholar; Mokyr, Joel, Why Ireland Starved: A Quantitative and Analytical History of the Irish Economy, 1800–1850 (London, 1983), 4:43–62, 264–94Google Scholar.

33 Kaeble, Harmut, “Social Mobility in America and Europe: A Comparison of Nineteenth Century Cities,” Urban History Yearbook (1981), pp. 24–38Google Scholar.

34 Hershberg, ed. (n. 5 above).

35 Anderson, Michael, Approaches to the History of the Western Family, 1500–1914 (London, 1986)Google Scholar.

36 Nicholas, S., ed., Convict Workers: Re-interpreting Australia's Past (Sydney, 1988)Google Scholar; Stewart, Hamish Maxwell, “The Bushrangers and the Convict System of Van Diemen's Land, 1803–1846” (Ph.D. diss., Edinburgh University, 1990)Google Scholar.

37 Quoted by Brock, Michael, The Great Reform Act (London, 1973), p. 143Google Scholar.

38 Quoted in ibid., p. 136.

39 Quoted by Cannon, John, Parliamentary Reform, 1640–1832 (Cambridge, 1973), p. 252Google Scholar.

40 Moore, D. C., “The Other Face of Reform,” Victorian Studies 5 (1961–1962): 9–34Google Scholar, and “Concession or Cure: The Sociological Premises of the First Reform Act,” Historical Journal 9 (1966): 39–54CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

41 Dicey, A. V., Law and Public Opinion in England during the 19th Century, 2d ed. (1885), p. 185Google Scholar, quoted by Cannon, p. 252.

42 Cole, G. D. H., A Short History of the British Working Class Movement, 1789–1925 (London, 1925), 1:100Google Scholar; Cole, G. D. H. and Postgate, Raymond, The Common People, 1746–1946 (London, 1938), p. 257Google Scholar; Hobsbawm, E. J., The Age of Revolution, 1789–1848 (London, 1962), p. 139Google Scholar.

43 Halevy, Elie, The Triumph of Reform, 1789–1848 (London, 1927), pp. 17, 62Google Scholar.

44 Woolley, S. F., “The Personnel of the Parliament of 1833,” English Historical Review 53 (1938): 240–62CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Aydelotte, W. O., “The House of Commons in the 1840s,” History 39 (1954): 249–62CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

45 Woodward, E. L., The Age of Reform, 1815–1870 (Oxford, 1938), pp. 84–88Google Scholar.

46 Briggs, Asa, “The Background of the Parliamentary Reform Movement in Three English Cities (1830–32),” Cambridge Historical Journal 10 (1950–1952): 293–317CrossRefGoogle Scholar, and “Middle Class Consciousness in English Politics, 1780–1846,” Past and Present, no. 9 (1956–1957), pp. 64–74Google Scholar; Lipset, Seymour Martin and Bendix, Reinhard, Social Mobility in Industrial Society (Berkeley, 1967)Google Scholar.

47 Vincent, John, Pollbooks: How Victorians Voted (Cambridge, 1967)Google Scholar.

48 These studies were related to survey-based studies of voting such as Butler, David and Stokes, D. E., Political Change in Britain (London, 1969)Google Scholar and to specific studies such as Budge, Ian and O'Leary, Cornelius, Belfast: Approach to Crisis: A Study of Belfast Politics, 1613–1970 (London, 1973)Google Scholar.

49 Goldthorpe, John H., Lockwood, David, Bechofer, Frank, and Platt, Jennifer, The Affluent Worker in the Class Structure (Cambridge, 1969)Google Scholar.

50 Vincent.

51 Nossitor, Tom, Influence, Opinion and Political Idioms in Reformed England: Case Studies from the North East, 1832–1874 (Brighton, 1975), pp. 172–73Google Scholar.

52 Neale, R. S., Class and Ideology in the Nineteenth Century (London, 1972), pp. 69–73Google Scholar, and Bath: A Social History, 1680–1850 (London, 1981), pp. 357–61Google Scholar.

53 Fraser, Derek, Urban Politics in Victorian England: The Structure of Politics in Victorian Cities (Leicester, 1976), pp. 229–31Google Scholar.

54 This was the practice of electors using only one of their two available votes in elections where there was only one candidate carrying their party label. A practice held to indicate strong party loyalties as it in effect “wasted” a vote.

55 Phillips, John, The Great Reform Bill in the Boroughs: English Electoral Behaviour, 1881–1941 (Oxford, 1992)Google Scholar; Phillips, John A. and Wetherell, Charles, “Probability and Political Behaviour: A Case Study of the Municipal Corporations Act of 1835,” History and Computing 5 (1993): 135–53Google Scholar; O'Gorman, Frank, Voters, Patrons and Parties: The Unreformed Electoral System in Hanoverian England, 1734–1832 (Oxford, 1989)Google Scholar, and “Electoral Behaviour in England, 1700–1872,” in Denley, , Fogelvik, , and Harvey, , eds. (n. 2 above), pp. 220–38Google Scholar.

56 Morris, R. J., Class, Sect and Party: The Making of the British Middle Class: Leeds, 1820–50 (Manchester, 1990)Google Scholar.

57 For surveys of two of the major sources referred to in this article, see Sims, John, ed., A Handlist of British Parliamentary Poll Books (Leicester and Riverside, Calif., 1984)Google Scholar; Shaw, Gareth and Tipper, Alison, British Directories: A Bibliography and Guide to Directories Published in England and Wales (1850–1950) and Scotland (1773–1950) (Leicester, 1988)Google Scholar.

58 Notably, Wrigley and Schofield (n. 31 above); on family and household, see Anderson, M. A., “Households, Families and Individuals: Some Preliminary Results from the National Sample from the 1851 Census of Great Britain,” Continuity and Change 3 (1988): 421–38CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

59 Foster, John, Class Struggle and the Industrial Revolution (London, 1974)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Gray, Robert Q., The Labour Aristocracy in Victorian Edinburgh (Oxford, 1976)Google Scholar; Crossick, Geoffrey, An Artisan Elite in Victorian Society (London, 1978)Google Scholar; Joyce, Patrick, Work, Society and Politics: The Culture of the Factory in Later Victorian England (Brighton, 1980)Google Scholar; Gatrell, V. A. C., “Incorporation and the Pursuit of Liberal Hegemony in Manchester, 1790–1839,” in Municipal Reform and the Industrial City, ed. Fraser, Derek (Leicester, 1982)Google Scholar.

60 These results are drawn together by Crafts (n. 31 above); and the volume of essays assembled by Mokyr, Joel, ed., The Economics of the Industrial Revolution (London, 1985)Google Scholar.

61 Hudson, Pat, ed., Regions and Industries: A Perspective on the Industrial Revolution in Britain (Cambridge, 1989), pp. 5–40CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

62 Baskerville, S. W., Hudson, Pat, and Morris, R. J., eds., “Special Issue: Record Linkage,” History and Computing, vol. 4 (1992)Google Scholar; Morris, R. J., “Does Nineteenth Century Nominal Record Linkage Have Lessons for the Machine Readable Century?” Journal of the Society of Archivists 7 (1985): 503–12CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

63 Kitts, Arno, Doulton, David, and Reis, Elizabeth, The Reconstitution of Viana do Castelo, Association for History and Computing (London, 1990)Google Scholar; Bouchard, Gérard, Brard, Patrick, and Lavoie, Yolande, “Fonem: Un code de transcription phonétique pour la reconstitution automatique des families Saguenayennes,” Population 36 (1981): 1085–1104CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Bouchard, Gerard and Pouyez, Christian, “Name Variations and Computerized Record Linkage,” Historical Methods 13 (Spring 1980): 119–25CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

64 Winchester, Ian, “The Linkage of Historical Records by Man and Computer: Techniques and Problems,” Journal of Inter-disciplinary History 1 (1970–1971): 107–24Google Scholar.

65 Baskerville, Stephen W., “‘Preferred Linkage’ and the Analysis of Voter Behaviour in Eighteenth Century England,” History and Computing 1 (1989): 112–20Google Scholar; Elkit, Jørgen, “Nominal Record Linkage and the Study of Non Secret Voting: A Danish Case,” Journal of Interdisciplinary History 15 (1985): 419–43CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

66 The technical details of this are in R. J. Morris, “The Leeds Middle Class, 1820–1850,” end of grant report to the Social Sciences Research Council, grant no. B/00/24/0003/1, copy in the British Library, Boston Spa, England.

67 See ibid.

68 For further information on the codes used, see Morris, R. J., “Occupational Coding: Principles and Examples,” Historical Social Research 15 (1990): 3–29Google Scholar, and “Fuller Values, Questions and Contexts: Occupational Coding and the Historian,” in The Use of Occupational Coding in Historical Analysis, ed. Shürer, Kevin and Diederiks, Herman, Max-Planck-Institut für Geschichte, Halbgraue Reihe zur historischen Fachinformatik (Göttingen, 1993)Google Scholar; Katz, M., “Occupational Classification in History,” Journal of Interdisciplinary History 3 (1972): 63–88CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

69 Holmes, David I., “A Multivariate Technique for Authorship Attribution and Its Application to the Analysis of Mormon Scripture and Related Texts,” History and Computing 3 (1991): 12–22Google Scholar; Allen, Robert F., “The Stylo Statistical Method of Literary Analysis,” Computers and the Humanities 22 (1988): 1–10Google Scholar; Roberts, Carl W. and Popping, Roel, “Computer Supported Content Analysis: Some Recent Developments,” Social Science Computer Review 11 (1993): 283–91CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

70 Jones, Gareth Stedman, Languages of Class: Studies in English Working Class History, 1832–1982 (Cambridge, 1983)Google Scholar; Joyce, Patrick, Visions of the People: Industrial England and the Question of Class, 1840–1914 (Cambridge, 1991)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

71 Leeds Mercury (February 12, 1832), report on the Leeds Reform Meeting; Leeds Mercury (February 16, 1833), report on the meeting of the Leeds Political Union.

72 Morris, R. J., “Samuel Smiles and the Genesis of Self Help,” Historical Journal 24 (1981): 89–109CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Tyrell, Alex, “Class Consciousness in Early Victorian Britain: Samuel Smiles, Leeds Politics and the Self Help Creed,” Journal of British Studies 9 (1970): 102–25CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Morris, R. J., “Samuel Smiles and Victorian Values: A Journey from Haddington to Leeds and London,” Transactions of the East Lothian Antiquarian and Field Natu-ralists Society 22 (1993): 63–80Google Scholar.

73 Mealand, David, “Computers in New Testament Research: An Interim Report,” Journal for the Study of the New Testament 33 (1988): 97–115CrossRefGoogle Scholar, and “Positional Stylomtry Reassessed: Testing a Seven Epistle Theory of Pauline Authorship,” New Testament Studies 35 (1989): 266–86CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

74 See the above discussion on pp. 507–8.

75 Ladurie, E. Le Roy, Le territoire de l'historien (Paris, 1973), p. 14Google Scholar, quoted by Mawdsley, Even and Munck, Thomas, Computing for Historians: An Introductory Guide (Manchester, 1993)Google Scholar; reactions included Stone, Lawrence, “The Revival of Narrative,” Past and Present, no. 85 (1979), pp. 3–24Google Scholar.

76 Shorter, Edward, The Historian and the Computer: A Practical Guide (Englewood Cliffs, N.J., 1971)Google Scholar; Floud, Roderick C., An Introduction to Quantitative Methods for Historians (London, 1973)Google Scholar.