Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-fbnjt Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-15T20:32:15.406Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Short-Selling Equity Exchange Traded Funds and Its Effect on Stock Market Liquidity

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  15 March 2021

Egle Karmaziene Open the ORCID record for Egle Karmaziene [Opens in a new window]  and
Valeri Sokolovski Open the ORCID record for Valeri Sokolovski [Opens in a new window]
Egle Karmaziene
Affiliation:
Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam Finance Departmente.karmaziene@vu.nl
Valeri Sokolovski*
Affiliation:
HEC Montréal Finance Department
*
valeri.sokolovski@hec.ca (corresponding author)
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

We examine short selling of equity exchange traded funds (ETFs) using the 2008 short-sale ban. Contrasting the previously documented contractions in bearish strategies during the ban, we find a significant increase in short sales of the largest, most liquid ETF, the S&P 500 Spider. We offer evidence suggesting that this upsurge was driven primarily by investors circumventing the ban. We show that the ban’s detrimental effect on stock liquidity was around 30% less severe for the Spider’s constituents. Our results suggest that ETF shorts can substitute for short sales of individual stocks, thereby alleviating short-sale constraints’ adverse effect on liquidity.

Type
Research Article
Information
Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis , Volume 57 , Issue 3 , May 2022 , pp. 923 - 956
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of the Michael G. Foster School of Business, University of Washington

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

The article was previously circulated as “Beware of the Spider: Exchange Traded Funds and the 2008 Short-Sale Ban.” We thank Bo Becker, Janis Berzins, David C. Brown (the referee), Tolga Cenesizoglu, Jaewon Choi, Jennifer Conrad (the editor), Magnus Dahlquist, Lammertjan Dam, Francesco Franzoni, Mariassunta Giannetti, Lawrence Glosten, Paul Hanouna, Bob Hodrick, Charles Jones, Bige Kahraman, Kathryn Kaminski, Markku Kaustia, Albert Menkveld, Simon Rottke, Kirsten Smart, Chester Spatt, Marti G. Subrahmanyam, Paul Tetlock, Tomas Thörnqvist, and Patrick Verwijmeren for their comments. We also thank the seminar and conference participants at the Bank of Lithuania, Columbia Business School, International Monetary Fund, 2018 International Risk Management Conference, McGill University, Mutual Funds, 2019 Hedge Funds and Factor Investing Conference, Swedish House of Finance, University of Cape Town, University of Groningen, Vilnius University, and Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam.

References

Agarwal, V.; Hanouna, P.; Moussawi, R.; and Stahel, C. W.. “Do ETFs Increase the Commonality in Liquidity of Underlying Stocks?” Working Paper, Georgia State University (2018).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Battalio, R., and Schultz, P.. “Regulatory Uncertainty and Market Liquidity: The 2008 Short Sale Ban’s Impact on Equity Option Markets.” Journal of Finance, 66 (2011), 2013–2053.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Beber, A., and Pagano, M.. “Short-Selling Bans Around the World: Evidence from the 2007–2009 Crisis.” Journal of Finance, 68 (2013), 343–381.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ben-David, I.; Franzoni, F.; and Moussawi, R.. “Do ETFs Increase Volatility?” Journal of Finance, 76 (2018), 2471–2535.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bhattacharya, A., and O’Hara, M.. “Can ETFs Increase Market Fragility? Effect of Information Linkages in ETF Markets.” Working Paper, Cornell University (2018).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Boehmer, E.; Jones, C. M.; and Zhang, X.. “Shackling Short Sellers: The 2008 Shorting Ban.” Review of Financial Studies, 26 (2013), 1363–1400.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brogaard, J.; Hendershott, T.; and Riordan, R.. “High Frequency Trading and the 2008 Short-Sale Ban.” Journal of Financial Economics, 124 (2017), 22–42.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brown, D. C.; Davies, S.; and Ringgenberg, M.. “ETF Arbitrage, Non-Fundamental Demand, and Return Predictability.” Review of Finance, 25 (2021), 937–972.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chen, H.; Noronha, G.; and Singal, V.. “The Price Response to S&P 500 Index Additions and Deletions: Evidence of Asymmetry and a New Explanation.” Journal of Finance, 59 (2004), 1901–1930.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Crump, R. K.; Hotz, V. J.; Imbens, G. W.; and Mitnik, O. A.. “Dealing with Limited Overlap in Estimation of Average Treatment Effects.” Biometrika, 96 (2009), 187–199.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Da, Z., and Shive, S.. “Exchange Traded Funds and Asset Return Correlations.” European Financial Management, 24 (2018), 136–168.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dannhauser, C. “The Impact of Innovation: Evidence from Corporate Bond Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs).” Journal of Financial Economics, 125 (2017), 537–560.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Diamond, D. W., and Verrecchia, R. E.. “Constraints on Short-Selling and Asset Price Adjustment to Private Information.” Journal of Financial Economics, 18 (1987), 277–311.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Drechsler, I., and Drechsler, Q. F.. “The Shorting Premium and Asset Pricing Anomalies.” NBER Working Paper No. 20282 (2014).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Elton, E. J.; Gruber, M. J.; Comer, G.; and Li, K.. “Spiders: Where Are the Bugs?” Journal of Business, 75 (2002), 453–472.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
ETFGI. “ETFGI Reports that Assets in ETFs/ETPs Listed Globally Are Again over the 6 Trillion US Dollar Milestone at the End of May 2020.” Press Release (2020).Google Scholar
Evans, R. B.; Moussawi, R.; Pagano, M. S.; and Sedunov, J.. “ETF Short Interest and Failures-to-Deliver: Naked Short-Selling or Operational Shorting?” Working Paper, Darden Business School (2019).Google Scholar
Figlewski, S., and Webb, G. P.. “Options, Short Sales, and Market Completeness.” Journal of Finance, 48 (1993), 761–777.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gastineau, G. L. “Chapter 4: Is Selling ETFs Short a Financial ‘Extreme Sport’?” In Short Selling: Strategies, Risks, and Rewards, Fabozzi, F. J., ed. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons (2004), 37–57.Google Scholar
Gastineau, G. L. The Exchange-Traded Funds Manual, Vol. 186. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons (2010).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Geczy, C. C.; Musto, D. K.; and Reed, A. V.. “Stocks Are Special Too: An Analysis of the Equity Lending Market.” Journal of Financial Economics, 66 (2002), 241–269.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Geraci, M.; Garbaravicius, T.; and Veredas, D.. “Short Selling in Extreme Events.” Journal of Financial Stability, 39 (2018), 90–103.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Glosten, L. R.; Nallareddy, S.; and Zou, Y.. “ETF Activity and Informational Efficiency of Underlying Securities.” Management Science, 67 (2020), 1–659.Google Scholar
Grundy, B. D.; Lim, B.; and Verwijmeren, P.. “Do Option Markets Undo Restrictions on Short Sales? Evidence from the 2008 Short-Sale Ban.” Journal of Financial Economics, 106 (2012), 331–348.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hamm, S. J. “The Effect of ETFs on Stock Liquidity.” Working Paper, Tulane University (2014).Google Scholar
Hegde, S. P., and McDermott, J. B.. “The Liquidity effects of revisions to the S&P 500 Index: An Empirical Analysis.” Journal of Financial Markets, 6 (2003), 413–459.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hendershott, T.; Namvar, E.; and Phillips, B.. “The Intended and Collateral Effects of Short Sale Bans as a Regulatory Tool.” Journal of Investment Management, 11 (2013), 5–13.Google Scholar
Holden, C. W., and Jacobsen, S. E.. “Liquidity Measurement Problems in Fast, Competitive Markets: Expensive and Cheap Solutions.” Journal of Finance, 69 (2014), 1747–1785.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Holden, C. W.; Jacobsen, S. E.; and Subrahmanyam, A.. “The Empirical Analysis of Liquidity.” Foundations and Trends in Finance, 8 (2014), 263–365.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Huang, S.; O’Hara, M.; and Zhong, Z.. “Innovation and Informed Trading: Evidence from Industry ETFs.” Review of Financial Studies, 34 (2021), 1280–1316.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Israeli, D.; Lee, C. M.; and Sridharan, S. A.. “Is There a Dark Side to Exchange Traded Funds? An Information Perspective.” Review of Accounting Studies, 22 (2017), 1048–1083.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jain, A.; Jain, P. K.; McInish, T. H.; and McKenzie, M.. “Worldwide Reach of Short Selling Regulations.” Journal of Financial Economics, 109 (2013), 177–197.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jones, C. M.; Reed, A. V.; and Waller, W.. “Revealing Shorts: An Examination of Large Short Position Disclosures.” Review of Financial Studies, 29 (2016), 3278–3320.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Khomyn, M.; Putnins, T. J.; and Zoican, M.. “The Value of ETF Liquidity.” Working Paper, University of Toronto (2020).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lee, C. M., and Ready, M. J.. “Inferring Trade Direction from Intraday Data.” Journal of Finance, 46, (1991), 733–746.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Li, F. W., and Zhu, Q.. “Short Selling ETFs.” Working Paper, Singapore Management University (2018).Google Scholar
McCaffrey, D. P. “Review of the Policy Debate over Short Sale Regulation During the Market Crisis.” Albany Law Review, 73 (2009), 483.Google Scholar
Newey, W. K., and West, K. D.. “A Simple, Positive Semi-Definite, Heteroskedasticity and Autocorrelation Consistent Covariance Matrix.” Econometrica, 55 (1987), 703–708.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Perez-Quiros, G., and Timmermann, A.. “Firm Size and Cyclical Variations in Stock Returns.” Journal of Finance, 55 (2000), 1229–1262.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Petajisto, A. “Inefficiencies in the Pricing of Exchange-Traded Funds.” Financial Analysts Journal, 73 (2017), 24–54.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sağlam, M.; Tuzun, T.; and Wermers, R.. “Do ETFs Increase Liquidity?” Working Paper, University of Cincinnati (2019).Google Scholar
Sirri, E. R. “Regulatory Politics and Short Selling.” University of Pittsburgh Law Review, 71 (2009), 517.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Staer, A., and Sottile, P.. “Equivalent Volume and Comovement.” Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance, 68 (2018), 143–157.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Welter, L. “European ETFs and the Securities Lending Market.” ETFs and Indexing, 2012 (2012), 135–139.Google Scholar
Supplementary material: PDF

Karmaziene and Sokolovski supplementary material

Karmaziene and Sokolovski supplementary material

Download Karmaziene and Sokolovski supplementary material(PDF)
PDF 285 KB