Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-t5tsf Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-14T22:29:51.322Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Difficulties in Rejecting a Local Ancestry With mtDNA Haplogroup Data in the South-Central Andes

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  20 January 2017

Cecil M. Lewis Jr.
Cecil M. Lewis Jr.*
Affiliation:
Department of Anthropology, University of Oklahoma, Norman, OK 73019 (cmlewis@ou.edu)
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This study assesses whether local genetic drift within populations can be rejected as a sufficient explanation for mitochondrial DNA haplogroup frequency changes between contemporary and prehistoric population samples in the South-Central Andes. Differences in the frequencies of haplogroups between populations are a popular line of evidence for assessing population history. The null hypothesis of haplo group frequency change is a stochastic force inherent to finite populations called genetic drift. Genetic drift is particularly influential in small populations. Innumerable historical events can result in low population sizes, and the simplest scenarios for these events are those occurring locally. In this study, simulations are used to provide a baseline for the amount of haplogroup-frequency difference expected from local genetic drift over time. The results from the simulations are compared to observed data from 23 population samples, including six prehistoric population samples. The study concludes that local genetic drift cannot be rejected when comparing a prehistoric population to a contemporary population. For the South-Central Andes, these results have dire consequences when attempting to infer genetic exchange. This study demonstrates that more informative genetic data are required for such inferences.

El presente estudio evalúa si la Deriva genética que ocurre entre poblaciones locales puede ser rechazada cuando se explican los cambios en las frecuencias de los haplogrupos observadas entre poblaciones contemporáneas y prehistóricas en la zona Sur Central de los Andes. La diferencia en las frecuencias de los haplogrupos mitocondriales entre poblaciones, ha sido una evidencia popular en la evaluación de la historia de poblaciones. La hipótesis nula de que las frecuencias de haplogrupos es un proceso estocástico inherente a poblaciones finitas es llamada Deriva gènica. La Deriva gènica es especialmente influyente en poblaciones pequeñas. Innumerables eventos históricos pueden resultar en periodos de tiempo en los cuales el tamaño de población es bajo; el escenario más simple envuelve eventos de ocurrencia local. En este estudio, se emplean simulaciones para generar una línea base para la magnitud de la diferencia en la frecuencia esperada para los haplogrupos a partir de la deriva génica local a través del tiempo. Los resultados de las simulaciones son comparados con los datos observados a partir de 23 muestras de poblaciones, incluyendo seis muestras de poblaciones prehistóricas. El estudio concluye que la deriva génica local no puede ser rechazada cuando se compara una población prehistórica con una población contemporánea. Para la zona Sur Central de los Andes, estos resultados tienen consecuencias directas en el intento de inferir intercambio genético. Este estudio demuestra que se requieren más datos genéticos para ese tipo de inferencias.

Type
Part 1: Themed Section on Tehnology Approaches
Information
Latin American Antiquity , Volume 20 , Issue 1 , March 2009 , pp. 76 - 90
Copyright
Copyright © 2009 by the Society for American Archaeology.

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

References Cited

Abbott, Mark, Binford, Michael W., Brenner, Mark, and Kelts, Kerry 1997 A 4500 l4C Yr High-Resolution Record of Water-Level Changes in Lake Titicaca, Bolivia-Peru. Quaternary Research 47:169–180.Google Scholar
Agresti, Alan 2001 Exact Inference for Categorical Data: Recent Advances and Continuing Controversies. Statistics inMedicine 20(17–18):2709–2722.Google ScholarPubMed
Bailliet, Graciela, Rothhammer, Francisco, Carnese, Francisco Raúl, Bravi, Claudio Marcelo, and Bianchi, Néstor Oscar 1994 Founder Mitochondrial Haplotypes in Amerindian Populations. American Journal of Human Genetics 55:27–33.Google ScholarPubMed
Bermann, Marc, Goldstein, Paul, Stanish, Charles, and Luis Watanabe, M. (editors) 1989 The Collapse of the Tiwanaku State: A View from the Osmore Drainage. British Archaeological Reports International Series, Oxford.Google Scholar
Bert, Francesc, Corella, Alfons, Gené, Manel, Pérez-Pérez, Alejandro, and Turbón, Daniel 2001 Major Mitochondrial DNA Haplotype Heterogeneity in Highland and Lowland Amerindian Populations from Bolivia. Human Biology 73:1–16.Google Scholar
Binford, Michael W., Kolata, Alan L., Brenner, Mark, Janusek, John W., Seddon, Matthew T., Abbott, Mark, and Curtis, Jason H. 1997 Climate Variation and the Rise and Fall of an Andean Civilization. Quaternary Research 47:235–248.Google Scholar
Blom, Deborah 1999 Tiwanaku Regional Interaction and Social Identity: A Bioarchaeological Approach. Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, Department of Anthropology, University of Chicago, Chicago.Google Scholar
Blom, Deborah E., Hallgrímsson, Benedikt, Keng, Linda, Lozada, María C., and Buikstra, Jane E. 1998 Tiwanaku “Colonization”: Biological Implications for Migration in the Moquegua Valley, Peru. World Archaeology 30:238–261.Google Scholar
Bonatto, Sandro L., and Salzano, Francisco M. 1997 A Single and Early Migration for the Peopling of the Americas Supported by Mitochondrial DNA Sequence Data. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, USA 94:1866–1871.Google Scholar
Carson, E. Ann 2006a Maximum Likelihood Estimation of Human Craniometric Heritabilities. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 131(2):169–180.Google Scholar
Carson, E. Ann 2006b Maximum-Likelihood Variance Components Analysis of Heritabilities of Cranial Nonmetric Traits. Human Biology 78(4):383–402.Google Scholar
Dornelles, Cláudia L., Bonatto, Sandro L., De Freitas, Loreta B., and Salzano, Francisco M. 2005 Is Haplogroup X Present in Extant South American Indians? American Journal of Physical Anthropology 127(4):439–448.Google Scholar
Falconer, Douglas S., and Mackay, Trudy F. C. 1996 Introduction to Quantitative Genetics. 4th ed. Prentice Hall, New York.Google Scholar
Fenner, Jack N. 2005 Cross-Cultural Estimation of the Human Generation Interval for Use in Genetics-Based Population Divergence Studies. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 128(2):415–423.Google Scholar
Fuselli, Silvia, Tarazona-Santos, Eduardo, Dupanloup, Isabelle, Soto, Alonso, Luiselli, Donata, and Pettener, Davide 2003 Mitochondrial DNA Diversity in South America and the Genetic History of Andean Highlanders. Molecular Biology and Evolution 20:1682–1691.Google Scholar
Gillespie, John H. 2000 Genetic Drift in an Infinite Population: The Pseudo-hitchhiking Model. Genetics 155(2):909–919.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gillespie, John H. 2004 Population Genetics. A Concise Guide. John Hopkins University Press, Baltimore.Google Scholar
Goldstein, Paul S. 1989a Omo, a Tiwanaku Provincial Center in Moquegua, Peru. Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, University of Chicago, Chicago.Google Scholar
Goldstein, Paul S. 1989b The Tiwanaku Occupation of Moquegua. In Ecology, Settlement and History in the Osmore Drainage, Perú, edited by Don S. Rice, Charles Stanish, and Phillip R. Scarr, pp. 219–266. BAR International Series, British Archaeological Reports, Oxford.Google Scholar
Goldstein, Paul S. 1992 Tiwanaku Temples and State Expansion. Latin American Antiquity 4:22–47.Google Scholar
Goldstein, Paul S. 1993 House, Community and State in the Earliest Tiwanaku Colony: Domestic Patterns and State Integration at Omo M12, Moquegua. In Domestic Architecture, Ethnicity, and Complementarity in the South Central-Andes, edited by Mark S. Aldenderfer, pp. 25–41. University of Iowa Press, Iowa City.Google Scholar
Goldstein, Paul S. 2000 Communities Without Borders: The Vertical Archipelago and Diaspora Communities in the Southern Andes. In The Archaeology of Communities: A New World Perspective, edited by Marcello A. Canuto and Jason Yaeger, pp. 182–209. Routledge, London.Google Scholar
Goldstein, Paul S. 2005 Andean Diaspora, the Tiwanaku Colonies and the Origins of South American Empire. University Press of Florida, Gainesville.Google Scholar
Gonder, Mary K., Mortensen, Holly M., Reed, Floyd A., Sousa, Alexandra de, and Tishkoff, Sarah A. 2007 Whole-mtDNA Genome Sequence Analysis of Ancient African Lineages. Molecular Biology Evolution 24(3):757–768.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Hey, Jody 2005 On the Number of New World Founders: A Population Genetic Portrait of the Peopling of the Americas. PLoS Biology 3(6):el93.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Janusek, John Wayne 2004 Tiwanaku and Its Precursors: Recent Research and Emerging Perspectives. Journal of Archaeological Research 12(2): 121–183.Google Scholar
Janusek, John Wayne, and Kolata, Allen L. 2004 Top-Down or Bottom-Up: Rural Settlement and Raised Field Agriculture in the Lake Titicaca Basin, Bolivia. Journal of Anthropological Archaeology 23:404–430.Google Scholar
Keefer, David K., Moseley, Michael E., and deFrance, Susan D. 2003 A 38,000-Year Record of Floods and Debris Flows in the Ilo Region of Southern Peru and Its Relation to El Niño Events and Great Earthquakes. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 194:41–77.Google Scholar
Kemp, Brian M., Malhi, Ripan S., McDonough, John, Bolnick, Deborah A., Eshleman, Jason A., Rickards, Olga, Martinez-Labarga, Cristina, Johnson, John R., Lorenz, Joseph G., James Dixon, E., Fifield, Terence E., Heaton, Timothy H., Worl, Rosita, and Smith, David Glenn 2007 Genetic Analysis of Early Holocene Skeletal Remains from Alaska and Its Implications for the Settlement of the Americas. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 132(4):605–621.Google Scholar
Kivisild, Toomas, Shen, Peidong, Wall, Dennis P., Do, Bao, Sung, Raphael, Davis, Karen, Passarino, Giuseppe, Underhill, Peter A., Scharfe, Curt, Torroni, Antonio, Scozzari, Rosaria, Modiano, David, Coppa, Alfredo, Knijff, Peter de, Feldman, Marcus, Cavalli-Sforza, Luca L., and Oefner, Peter J. 2006 The Role of Selection in the Evolution of Human Mitochondrial Genomes. Genetics 172(1):373–387.Google Scholar
Knudson, Kelly 2004 Tiwanaku Residential Mobility in the South Central Andes: Identifying Archaeological Human Migration Through Strontium Isotope Analysis. Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, Department of Anthropology, University of Wisconsin, Madison.Google Scholar
Knudson, Kelly, Douglas Price, T., Buikstra, Jane E., and Blom, Deborah 2004 The Use of Strontium Isotope Analysis to Investigate Tiwanaku Migration and Mortuary Ritual in Bolivia and Peru. Archaeometry 46:5–18.Google Scholar
Kolata, A. L. 1992 Economy, Ideology, and Imperialism in the South-Central Andes. In Ideology and Pre-Columbian Civilizations, edited by Arthur A. Demarest and Geoffrey W. Conrad, pp. 65–86. School of American Research Press, Santa Fe.Google Scholar
Kolata, A. L., and Ortloff, C. R. 1996 Agro-Ecological Perspectives on the Decline of the Tiwanaku State. In Tiwanaku and Its Hinterland: Archaeology and Paleoecology of an Andean Civilization, Vol. I, edited by Alan L. Kolata, pp. 181–202. Smithsonian Institution Press, Washington, D.C.Google Scholar
Lewis, Cecil M. Jr., Buikstra, Jane E., and Stone, Anne C. 2007a Ancient DNA and Genetic Continuity in the South Central Andes. Latin American Antiquity 18(2): 145–160.Google Scholar
Lewis, Cecil M. Jr., Lizárraga, Beatriz, Tito, Raul Y., López, Pual W., lannacone, GianCarlo, Medina, Angel, Martínez, Rolando, Polo, Susan I., Cruz, Augusto F. d. I., Cáceres, Angela M., and Stone, Anne C. 2007b Mitochondrial DNA and the Peopling of South America. Human Biology 79(2): 159–178.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Lewis, Cecil M. Jr., and Long, Jeff C. 2008 Native South American Genetic Structure and Prehistory Inferred from Hierarchical Modeling of mtDNA. Molecular Biology and Evolution 25(3):478–486.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Lewis, Cecil M. Jr., Tito, Raul Y., Lizarraga, Beatriz, and Stone, Anne C. 2004 Land, Language, and Loci: mtDNA in Native Americans and the Genetic History of Peru. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 127:351–360.Google Scholar
Luiselli, Donata, Simoni, Lucia, Tarazona-Santos, Eduardo, Pastor, Santiago, and Pettener, Davide 2000 Genetic Structure of Quechua-Speakers of the Central Andes and Geographic Patterns of Gene Frequencies in South Amerindian Populations. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 113:5–17.Google Scholar
Merriwether, D. Andrew, Ferrell, Robert E., and Roth-hammer, Francisco 1995 MtDNA D-loop 6-bp Deletion Found in Chilean Aymara: Not a Unique Marker for Chibcha-Speaking Amerindians. American Journal of Human Genetics 56:812–813.Google Scholar
Mishmar, Dan, Ruiz-Pesini, Eduardo, Golik, Pawel, Macaulay, Vincent, Clark, Andrew G., Hosseini, Seyed, Brandon, Martin, Easley, Kirk, Chen, Easley, Brown, Michael D., Sukernik, Rem I., Olckers, Antonel, and Wallace, Douglas C. 2003 Natural Selection Shaped Regional mtDNA Variation in Humans. Proceeding of the National Academy of Sciences, USA 100(1):171–176.Google Scholar
Moraga, Mauricio L., Aspillaga, Eugenio, Santoro, Calogero, Standen, Vivien, Carvallo, Pilar, and Rothhammer, Francisco 2001 MtDNA Analysis of Mummies from Northern Chile Endorse the Hypothesis of an Amazonian Origin of Andean Populations. Revista Chilena de Historia Natural 74:719–726.Google Scholar
Moraga, Mauricio L., Santoro, Calogero, Standen, Vivien G., Carvallo, Pilar, and Rothhammer, Francisco 2005 Microevolution in Prehistoric Andean Populations: Chronologic mtDNA Variation in the Desert Valleys of Northern Chile. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 127:170–181.Google Scholar
Mujica, Elias 1985 Altiplano-Coast Relationships in the South-Central Andes: From Indirect to Direct Complementarity. In Andean Ecology and Civilization, edited by Shozo Masuda, Izumi Shimada, and Craig Morris, pp. 103–140. University of Tokyo, Tokyo.Google Scholar
Nei, Masatoshi 1987 Molecular Evolutionary Genetics. Columbia University Press, New York.Google Scholar
Owen, Bruce D. 2005 Distant Colonies and Explosive Collapse: The Two Stages of the Tiwanaku Diaspora in the Osmore Drainage. Latin American Antiquity 16(1):45–80.Google Scholar
Reycraft, Richard M. 1998 The Terminal Chiribaya Project: The Archaeology of Human Response to Natural Disaster in South Coastal Perú. Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, University of New Mexico, Albuquerque.Google Scholar
Reycraft, Richard M. 2000 Long-Term Human Response to El Niño in South Coastal Perú, Circa A.D. 1400. In Environmental Disaster and the Archaeology of Human Response, edited by G. Bawden and R. M. Reycraft, pp. 99–120. Anthropological Papers No. 7. Maxwell Museum of Anthropology, Albuquerque.Google Scholar
Rothhammer, Francisco, Moraga, Mauricio, Rivera, Mario, Santoro, Calogero, Standen, Vivien G., García, Federico, and Carvallo, Pilar 2003 Análisis de ADNmt de Restos Esqueletales del Sitio Arqueológico de Tiwanakiu y su Relatión con el Origen de sus Constructores. Chungará 35:269–274.Google Scholar
Rothhammer, Francisco, and Santoro, Calogero 2001 El desarrollo cultural en el valle de Azapa, extremo norte de Chile, y su vinculación con los desplazamientos poblacionales altiplanicos. Latin American Antiquity 12:59–66.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Satterlee, Dennis 1993 Impact of a Fourteenth Century El Niño on an Indigenous Population near llo, Perú. Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, University of Florida, Gainesville.Google Scholar
Silva, Wilson A. Jr., Bonatto, Sandro L., Holanda, Adriano J., Ribeiro-dos-Santos, Andrea K., Paixão, Beatriz M., Goldman, Gustavo H., Abe-Sandes, Kiyoko, Rodriguez-Delfin, Luis, Barbosa, Marcela, Paçó-Larson, Maria Luiza, Petzl-Erler, Maria Luiza, Valente, Valeria, Santos, Sidney E.B., and Zago, Marco A. 2002 Mitochondrial Genome Diversity of Native Americans Supports a Single Early Entry of Founder Populations into America. American Journal of Human Genetics 71(1):187–192.Google Scholar
Sutter, Richard C. 2000 Prehistoric Genetic and Culture Change: A Bioarchaeological Search for Pre-Inka Altiplano Colonies in the Coastal Valleys of Moquegua, Peru, and Azapa, Chile. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 11(1):43–70.Google Scholar
Sutter, Richard C, and Mertz, Lisa 2004 Nonmetric Cranial Trait Variation and Prehistoric Bio-cultural Change in the Azapa Valley, Chile. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 123(2): 130–145.Google Scholar
Tarazona-Santos, Eduardo, Carvalho-Silva, Denise R., Pettener, Davide, Luiselli, Donata, Stefano, Gian Franco De, Labarga, Cristina Martinez, Rickards, Olga, Tyler-Smith, Chris, Pena, Sérgio D. J., and Santos, Fabricio R. 2001 Genetic Differentiation in South Amerindians Is Related to Environmental and Cultural Diversity: Evidence from the Y Chromosome. American Journal of Human Genetics 68:1485–1496.Google Scholar
Torero, Alfredo 2003 Idiomas de los Andes, Lingüística e Historia. Institute Francés de Estudios Andinos Editorial Horizonte, Lima.Google Scholar
Wang, Sijia, Lewis, Cecil M. Jr., Jakobsson, Mattias, Ramachandran, Sohini, Ray, Nicolas, Bedoya, Gabriel, Rojas, Winston, Parra, Maria V., Molina, Julio A., Gallo, Carla, Mazzotti, Guido, Poletti, Giovanni, Hill, Kim, Hurtado, Ana M., Labuda, Damian, Klitz, William, Barrantes, Ramiro, Bortolini, Maria Cátira, Salzano, Francisco M., Petzl-Erler, Maria Luiza, Tsuneto, Luiza T., Llop, Elena, Rothhammer, Francisco, Excoffier, Laurent, Feldman, Marcus W., Rosenberg, Noah A., and Ruiz-Linares, Andrés 2007 Genetic Variation and Population Structure in Native Americans. PLoS Genetics 3(11):el85.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Workman, P. L., and Niswander, J. D. 1970 Population Studies on Southwestern Indian Tribes. II. Local Genetic Differentiation in the Papago. American Journal Human Genetics 22(1):24–49.Google ScholarPubMed
Zaro, Gregory 2005 Human Ecology and Ancient Agrarian Land Use at Wawakiki Spring, South Coast Peru, A.D. 1000–2000. Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, University of New Mexico, Albuquerque.Google Scholar