Restraint, Reaction, and Penal Fantasies: Notes on the Death Penalty in Israel, 1967–2016

Ron Dudai

doi:10.1111/lsi.12293

Restraint, Reaction, and Penal Fantasies: Notes on the Death Penalty in Israel, 1967–2016

Published online by Cambridge University Press: 27 December 2018

Ron Dudai

Article contents

Abstract
References

Get access

Rights & Permissions

Abstract

What role does the death penalty play in contexts of protracted political violence? What does it symbolize for its opponents and proponents in such contexts? Can it survive as a potent topic of political life even without actual executions? Since 1967, the death penalty has been a lawful sanction in Israel's military courts, which have jurisdiction over Palestinians in the Occupied Territories. Though it has never been carried out, it has been intensely debated throughout this period and the topic has retained major political, cultural, and judicial significance. I argue that both sides in these debates use the topic mostly symbolically, rather than as an issue of public policy. For opponents, refraining from using the death penalty has become a symbol of restraint, used in self-legitimation. For proponents, death penalty advocacy serves as what I term a penal fantasy, an outlet for frustration, symbolizing defiance against the image of restraint.

Type: Articles
Information: Law & Social Inquiry , Volume 43 , Issue 3 , Summer 2018 , pp. 862 - 888

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/lsi.12293 [Opens in a new window]
Copyright: Copyright © American Bar Foundation, 2018

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Alexandrowicz, Ra'anan. n.d. The Law in these Parts [movie]. https://www.thelawfilm.com/ (accessed December 2016).Google Scholar

Alon, Gideon. 1994. In Favor and Against the Death Penalty: A Survey. Attorney April:31–32.Google Scholar

Aridor, Yoram. 1989. The Death Penalty? Unfeasible. Moked—Land of Israel, October, 35.Google Scholar

Bae, Sangmin. 2009. South Korea's De Facto Abolition of the Death Penalty. Pacific Affairs 82:407–25.Google Scholar

Balbus, Isaac. 1973. The Dialectics of Legal Repression. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.Google Scholar

Banner, Stuart. 2002. The Death Penalty: An American History. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar

Barak, Aharon. 1978. Imposing Death Penalty for Terrorists: Considerations in Favor and Against. Annex II to Letter from Barak to Minister of Justice Tamir, Titled “Death Penalty to Terrorists.” March 14. Israel State Archives, Folder 7005/33a.Google Scholar

Barker, Rodney. 2001. Legitimating Identities: The Self-Presentation of Rulers and Subjects. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar

Bazaq, Jacob. 1981. Criminal Punishment: Methods and Principles. Jerusalem: Dvir.Google Scholar

Ben-Ari, Michael. 2011. The Time Has Come for the Death Penalty. Channel 7, April 21.Google Scholar

Ben-Gurion, David. 1968. Death Penalty to Terrorists, Respect to Arab Soldiers. Ha'aretz, December 26.Google Scholar

Ben-Haim, Ofer. 1989. The Death Penalty in the Case Law of the Military Courts in Israel and the Administered Territories. IDF Law Review 10:35–67.Google Scholar

Ben-Joseph, Z. 1989. A Survey—Death Penalty to Terrorists: Yes or No? Moked—Land of Israel, September.Google Scholar

Ben-Naftali, O., and Michaeli, K. R. 2003. We Must Not Make a Scarecrow of the Law: A Legal Analysis of the Israeli Policy of Targeted Killings. Cornell International Law Journal 36:233–92.Google Scholar

Ben-Natan, Smadar. 2014. The Application of Israeli Law in the Military Courts. Theory and Criticism 43:45–74.Google Scholar

Bernstein, David. 1985. Israel's Tougher Line on Killings Likely to Fall Short of Death Penalty. Times, July 29.Google Scholar

Besheva. 2007. Question of the Week: Is it Right to Apply Death Penalty for Terrorists? Besheva, January 4.Google Scholar

Channel 7. 2002. Attorney General: Death Penalty Will Not Be Imposed on Terrorists. Channel 7, October 18.Google Scholar

Cohen, Esther. 1985. Human Rights in the Israeli-Occupied Territories, 1967–1982. Manchester: Manchester University Press.Google Scholar

Cohen, Geula. 1985. Deterioration of Security and the Need to Impose Death Penalty in Special Cases. Knesset Motion, January 1.Google Scholar

Cohen, Stanley. 1996. Government Responses to Human Rights Reports: Claims, Denials, and Counterclaims. Human Rights Quarterly 18:517–43.Google Scholar

Cohen, Stanley. 2001. States of Denial: Knowing About Atrocities and Suffering. Cambridge: Polity.Google Scholar

Cohen, Stanley, and Taylor, Laurie. 1992. Escape Attempts: The Theory and Practice of Resistance to Everyday Life, 2d ed. London: Routledge.Google Scholar

Davar. 1972. The Terrorist Who Left a Bomb in Netanya Sentenced to Death. Davar, September 25.Google Scholar

Disenchik, Ido. 1985. Death Penalty Now. Ma'ariv, July 26.Google Scholar

Doron, Shai. 2014. Anger in the Political System After the Finding of the Bodies. Nana News, June 30.Google Scholar

Dotan, Yoav. 2001. The Global Language of Human Rights: Patterns of Cooperation Between State and Civil Rights Lawyers in Israel. In Cause Lawyering and the State in a Global Era, ed. Sarat, Austin, 244–63. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar

Doyle, M. 2015. Republicans, Martyrology, and the Death Penalty in Britain and Ireland, 1939–1990. Journal of British Studies 54:703–22.Google Scholar

Drucker, Raviv. 2015. Attorney General Weinstein: “I Will Resign if Death Penalty Is Imposed in Israel.” Nana10 News, July 12.Google Scholar

Dudai, Ron. 2009. Can You Describe This? Human Rights Reports and What They Tell Us About the Human Rights Movement. In Humanitarianism and Suffering, ed. Wilson, R. and Brown, R., 245–64. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar

Eichensehr, Kirsten. 2007. On Target? The Israeli Supreme Court and the Expansion of Targeted Killings. Yale Law Journal 116:1873–81.Google Scholar

Elizur, Uri. 1995. Naïve Judges. Nekuda 185:74–75.Google Scholar

Ezra, H. 2011. A Lobby in the Knesset for Applying Death Penalty on Terrorists Murders. Channel 7, November 29.Google Scholar

Fechter, A. 2011. Why Not Impose the Death Penalty? http://www.news1.co.il/Archive/003-D-59012-00.html (accessed December 2016).Google Scholar

Feiglin, Moshe. 2015. Interview with Channel 20. http://www.srugim.co.il/120426-%D7%94%D7%95%D7%A6%D7%90%D7%AA-%D7%9E%D7%97%D7%91%D7%9C%D7%99%D7%9D-%D7%9C%D7%94%D7%95%D7%A8%D7%92-%D7%9E%D7%A9%D7%94-%D7%A4%D7%99%D7%99%D7%92%D7%9C%D7%99%D7%9F-%D7%9E%D7%95%D7%9C-%D7%94%D7%A8%D7%91 (accessed December 2016).Google Scholar

Foucault, Michel. 1977. Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison. New York: Vintage.Google Scholar

Frish, Felix. 2003. Military Court: Consider Death Penalty for Terrorists. Ynet, March 25.Google Scholar

Fuchs, Yossi. 2014. The Time Has Come: Death Penalty Terrorists. Legal Forum for the Land of Israel, November 17.Google Scholar

Galili, Lili. 2006. Liberman: Death Penalty for Terrorists. Ha'aretz, February 21.Google Scholar

Ganor, Boaz. 1989. Death Penalty Opponents Have Mistaken Assumptions. Moked—Land of Israel, September, 16–17.Google Scholar

Garland, David. 1996. The Limits of the Sovereign State: Strategies of Crime Control in Contemporary Society. British Journal of Criminology 36:445–71.Google Scholar

Garland, David. 2005. Penal Excess and Surplus Meaning: Public Torture Lynchings in Twentieth-Century America. Law & Society Review 39:793–834.Google Scholar

Garland, David. 2007. Rethinking the Symbolic-Instrumental Distinction. In Governance and Regulation in Social Life, ed. Brannigan, A. and Pavlich, G., 109–30. New York: Routledge.Google Scholar

Garland, David. 2010. Peculiar Institution: America's Death Penalty in the Age of Abolition. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar

Gazit, Shlomo. 1985. The Carrot and the Stick in the Occupied Territories. Tel-Aviv: Dvir.Google Scholar

Gearty, Conor. 2006 Can Human Rights Survive? Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar

Golan, Asaf. 2014. The Only Real Solution for Terrorists Release. NRG, March 24.Google Scholar

Gordon, Niv. 2008. Israel's Occupation. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar

Grossman, David. 2003. Death as a Way of Life: Israel Ten Years After Oslo. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux.Google Scholar

Ha'aretz. 1994. Rabin: I'll Ask the Chief of Staff to Commute the Death Penalty. Ha'aretz, November 27.Google Scholar

Ha'aretz. 2014. The Minister Determined: Death Penalty. Ha'aretz, November 7.Google Scholar

Hanegbi, Moshe. 2015. The Lynch Culture of the Right-Wing. Ha'aretz, November 3.Google Scholar

Harif, Joseph. 1979. I Speak in Behalf of the IDF No Less than You, Begin Said to Weitzman in Response to Comment That the IDF Opposes the Death Penalty. Ma'ariv, May 4.Google Scholar

Hay, Douglas. 1975. Property, Authority and the Criminal Law. In Albion's Fatal Tree, ed. Thompson, E. P. et al., 17–63. London: Allen Lane.Google Scholar

Hood, Roger, and Hoyle, Carolyn. 2009. Abolishing the Death Penalty Worldwide: The Impact of a “New Dynamic.” Crime and Justice 38:1–63.Google Scholar

Hood, Roger, and Carolyn, Hoyle. 2014. The Death Penalty: A Worldwide Perspective. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar

Horowitz, Mardi. 2007. Understanding and Ameliorating Revenge Fantasies in Psychotherapy. American Journal of Psychiatry 164:24–27.Google Scholar

Imseis, Ardi. 2003. On the Fourth Geneva Convention and the Occupied Palestinian Territory. Harvard International Law Journal 44:65–138.Google Scholar

Indor, Meir. 2011. Death Penalty for Terrorists. Ha'aretz, April 26.Google Scholar

Israeli Foreign Ministry. n.d. Presenting Israel's Case Before International Human Rights Bodies. http://mfa.gov.il/MFA/AboutIsrael/State/Law/Pages/Presenting%20Israel-s%20Case%20before%20International%20Huma.aspx (accessed December 2016).Google Scholar

Jewish Telegraphic Agency. 1974. Israel to Consider Re-Instating the Death Penalty for Terrorists. Jewish Telegraphic Agency, May 23.Google Scholar

Jewish Telegraphic Agency. 1985. Israel to Review Death Penalty for Terrorists Convicted of Capital Crimes. Jewish Telegraphic Agency, July 26.Google Scholar

Jewish Voice. 2014. Almagor Demands: Death Penalty to Terrorists. Jewish Voice, September 17.Google Scholar

Johnson, David. 2011. American Capital Punishment in Comparative Perspective. Law & Social Inquiry 36 (4): 1033–61.Google Scholar

Johnson, David, and Zimring, Franklin. 2009. The Next Frontier: National Development, Political Change, and the Death Penalty in Asia. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar

Joint Statement of Nine Human Rights Organizations. 2015. Politicians Call on Police and Soldiers to Kill Rather Than Arrest. October 20. http://www.acri.org.il/en/2015/10/20/politicians-call-to-kill/ (accessed December 2016).Google Scholar

Kretzmer, David. 2002. The Occupation of Justice: The Supreme Court of Israel and the Occupied Territories. Albany, NY: SUNY Press.Google Scholar

Lafarge, Lucy. 2006. The Wish for Revenge. Psychoanalytic Quarterly 75:447–75.Google Scholar

Lapid, Yosef. 1987. The Sting in the Death Penalty. Ma'ariv, June 7.Google Scholar

Lavi, Shai. 2005. Imagining the Death Penalty in Israel: Punishment, Violence, Vengeance and Revenge. In The Cultural Lives of the Death Penalty, ed. Sarat, A. and Boulinger, C., 219–30. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.Google Scholar

Lev, Yigal. 1987. Hanging Common Sense. Ma'ariv, October 16.Google Scholar

Levinson, Haim. 2011. Interrogation of Murders of Fogel Family Ended; IDF Will Ask Imposing the Death Penalty. Ha'aretz, May 20.Google Scholar

Libai, David, and Sheleff, Leon. 1975. Symposium on Capital Punishment. Acta Juridica 236–45.Google Scholar

Light, M., and Kovalev, N. 2013. Russia, the Death Penalty, and Europe. Post-Soviet Affairs 29 (6): 528–66.Google Scholar

Limor, Yehiel. 1967. The Expected Punishment for the Accused: Death. Ma'ariv, October 16.Google Scholar

Lin, Amnon. 1976. Fighting Arab Terrorism, and Methods of Punishment in Relation to Terrorists. Knesset Motion, July 14.Google Scholar

Lis, Yonathan. 2015. Netanyahu Buries the Death Penalty to Terrorists Bill. Ha'aretz, July 12.Google Scholar

Loader, Ian. 2010. For Penal Moderation: Notes Towards a Public Philosophy of Punishment. Theoretical Criminology 14:349–67.Google Scholar

Loader, Ian, and Mulcahy, Aogan. 2003. Policing and the Condition of England: Memory, Politics and Culture. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar

Lotan, A. 2014. The Mayor Initiates a Petition: Death Penalty for Terrorists. Ynet News, July 3.Google Scholar

Ma'ariv. 1985. Shamir: The Government Will Discuss Death Penalty to Terrorists. Ma'ariv, July 26.Google Scholar

Ma'ariv. 2015. Members of Parliament Try to Convince You: In Favor and Against Death Penalty to Terrorists. Ma'ariv, July 9.Google Scholar

Mann, Rafi. 1985. Military Prosecutor Will Be Required to Consult Ministers on Whether to Ask for Death Penalty. Ma'ariv, August 1.Google Scholar

Margalit, Lila, and Darsham-Leitner, Nitsana. 2002. Should Those Who Assisted Suicide Bombers be Given the Death Penalty? Jerusalem Report, December 2.Google Scholar

Margalit, Michal. 2014. A Wave of Calls for Revenge: “Death to Arabs.” Ynet News, July 2.Google Scholar

McGowen, Randall. 2011. Introduction: Getting the Question Right? Ways of Thinking About Death Penalty. In America's Death Penalty: Between Past and Present, ed. Garland, D., McGowen, R., and Meranze, M., 01–29. New York: NYU Press.Google Scholar

Meiri, B. 1987. Sharir Recommends: Apply the Death Penalty on Particularly Severe Crimes. Ma'ariv, October 13.Google Scholar

Moria, S. 2014. Prevent National Disgrace: Death Penalty to the Killers of the Youths. NRG, July 1.Google Scholar

Neumayer, Eric. 2008. Death Penalty: The Political Foundations of the Global Trend Towards Abolition. Human Rights Review 9:241–68.Google Scholar

Oppenhaimer, Yariv. 2011. On Life and Death. NRG, October 25.Google Scholar

Pach, Arie. 1977. Human Rights in the West Bank Military Courts. Israel Yearbook of Human Rights 7:222–52.Google Scholar

Page, Joshua. 2012. Punishment and the Penal Field. In The Sage Handbook of Punishment and Society, ed. Simon, J. and Sparks, R., 152–66. London: Sage.Google Scholar

Pratt, John. 2007. Penal Populism. London: Routledge.Google Scholar

Putshovsky, David. 1972. On Penalties to Murderous Terrorists. Nation 10:177–88.Google Scholar

Putshovsky, Shlomo. 2014. The Legal Forum: Demand Death Penalty to Terrorists. Channel 7, July 3.Google Scholar

Ron, James. 2000. Savage Restraint: Israel, Palestine and the Dialectics of Legal Repression. Social Problems 47:445–72.Google Scholar

Rozner, Tal. 2011. Who Will Die and Who Will Live. Makor Rishon, October 7.Google Scholar

Rubinstein, Amnon. 1987. On the Death Penalty. Ha'aretz, May 31.Google Scholar

Sangero, Boaz. 2000. On Capital Punishment in General and on the Death Penalty for Murder Committed During a Terrorist Act in Particular. Alei Mishpat 2:127–203.Google Scholar

Sarat, Austin. 1999. Capital Punishment as a Legal, Political, and Cultural Fact: An Introduction. In The Killing State: Capital Punishment in Law, Politics, and Culture, ed. Sarat, Austin, 3–19. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar

Scott, James C. 1990. Domination and the Arts of Resistance: Hidden Transcripts. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.Google Scholar

Sedan, Gil. 1985. Cabinet Again Delays Discussion on Death Penalty for Terrorist Killers. Jewish Telegraphic Agency, August 5.Google Scholar

Sedan, Gil. 1988. Israel to Consider Death Penalty. Jewish Telegraphic Agency, November 14.Google Scholar

Sedan, Gil. 1989. Israel Could Impose Death Penalty on Three Convicted of Firebombing. Jewish Telegraphic Agency, December 14.Google Scholar

Segev, Tom. 2007. 1967: Israel, The War and the Year That Transformed the Middle East. New York: Metropolitan Books.Google Scholar

Sha'ari, Yehuda. 1974. Implementing Death Penalty for Terrorist Murderers. Knesset Motion, May 22.Google Scholar

Shamgar, Meir. 1982. Legal Concepts and Problems of the Israeli Military Government—The Initial Stage. In Military Government in the Territories Administrated by Israel, 1967–1980: The Legal Aspects, ed. Shamgar, Meir, 13–60. Jerusalem: Hebrew University of Jerusalem.Google Scholar

Shashar, Michael. 1997. The Seventh Day War: The Diary of the Military Administration in Judea and Samaria, June-December 1967. Tel Aviv: Poalim.Google Scholar

Shefi, Dov. 1981. Middle East: Law or War? Interview with Dave Browning. Poly Law Review 6:72–83.Google Scholar

Shefi, Dov. 1982. The Reports of the UN Special Committees on Israel Practices in the Territories—A Survey and Evaluation. In Military Government in the Territories Administrated by Israel, 1967–1980: The Legal Aspects, ed. Shamgar, M., 285–334. Jerusalem: Hebrew University of Jerusalem.Google Scholar

Sheizaf, Noam. 2015. The Death Penalty is Making a Comeback in Israel. 972mag, July 9.Google Scholar

Simon, Jonathan. 1995. They Died with Their Boots On: The Boot Camp and the Limits of Modern Penality. Social Justice 22:25–48.Google Scholar

Simon, Jonathan, and Christina, Spaulding. 1999. Tokens of Our Esteem: Aggravating Factors in the Era of Deregulated Death Penalties. In The Killing State: Capital Punishment in Law, Politics, and Culture, ed. Sarat, Austin, 81–113. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar

Straschnov, Amnon. 1999. The Judicial System in Israel. Tulsa Law Journal 34:527–36.Google Scholar

Whitman, James. 2003. Harsh Justice: Criminal Punishment and the Widening Divide Between America and Europe. New York: Oxford University Press Google Scholar

Yashuvi, Na'ama. 1992 Activity of the Undercover Units in the Occupied Territories. Jerusalem: B'Tselem.Google Scholar

Yavne, Lior. 2007. Backyard Proceedings: The Implementation of Due Process Rights in the Military Courts in the Occupied Territories. Tel Aviv: Yesh Din.Google Scholar

Zadok, Haim. 1993. And What if the Death Penalty for Terrorists Would be Imposed? Yediot Ahronot, June 14.Google Scholar

Ze'evi, Rehavam. 1985. Death—Yes, Death Penalty—No? Yediot Ahronot, August 11.Google Scholar

Zimring, Franklin. 2003. The Contradictions of American Capital Punishment. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar

Judea Military Court, 2437/08, February 19, 2009.Google Scholar

Military Prosecutor v. Abduallah Barghouti, Judea Military Court, November 30, 2004.Google Scholar

Military Prosecutor v. Adnan Jabbar and others, Ramallah Military Court, 81 November/81 November 11, 1981.Google Scholar

Military Prosecutor v. Ahmad Taqruri and others, Ramallah Military Court, 3009/89, December 20, 1989.Google Scholar

Military Prosecutor v. Amjad Abidi and others, Samaria Military Court, 5205/64, February 19, 2004.Google Scholar

Military Prosecutor v. Hakim Awwad, Samaria Military Court, 2395/11, September 13, 2011.Google Scholar

Military Prosecutor v. Mahmood Harshe and others, Nablus Military Court, 7812/89, July 7, 1993.Google Scholar

Military Prosecutor v. Na'aman Shalbi, Jenin Military Court, 8154/92, October 25, 1992.Google Scholar

Military Prosecutor v. Ra'ad Sheikh, Judea Military Court, 45489/00, September 7, 2003.Google Scholar

Military Prosecutor v. Tourkman, Jenin Military Court, 8927/92, December 16, 1992.Google Scholar

Ra'ad Sheikh v. Military Prosecutor, Military Appeals Court, 310/03, March 3, 2004.Google Scholar

Said Badarne v. Military Prosecutor, Jenin Military Court, 282/94, February 23, 1995.Google Scholar

Samaria Military Court, Cases 6165/02 and others, April 14, 2003.Google Scholar

Sharif Naji v. Military Prosecutor, Military Appeals Court, 63/04, October 25, 2004.Google Scholar

Defense (Emergency) Regulations (1945).Google Scholar

Fourth Geneva Convention (1949).Google Scholar

Order Regarding Security Regulations (1970).Google Scholar