It is commonly accepted that Black and White Americans hold divergent
views about the criminal justice system. Furthermore, many accept the
view that U.S. public opinion is unflinchingly punitive where issues of
criminal justice policy are concerned, with this punitiveness among
White Americans deriving to a significant degree from anti-Black
prejudice. Using a series of survey-based experiments and large,
nationally representative samples of White and African American
respondents, we subject the questions of Black-White polarization,
unyielding punitiveness, and the influence of racial prejudice to close
scrutiny. Our results, first, confirm large Black-White differences in
opinion with Blacks consistently less punitive than Whites. These
differences are substantially a result of beliefs about the extent of
racial bias in the criminal justice system. Second, the framing
experiments suggest that responses to the death penalty are very
different than responses to drug-related crimes like crack or powder
cocaine use, with the former exhibiting far less malleability than the
latter. Third, racial prejudice is a consistently large influence on
White public opinion and a weaker, but sometimes important influence
among Blacks as well. Implications for discourse on race and crime are
also discussed.