Recent theoretical and experimental investigations have revealed that flapping compliant membrane wings can significantly enhance propulsive performance (e.g. Tzezana & Breuer J. Fluid Mech., 2019, vol. 862, pp. 871–888) and energy harvesting efficiency (e.g. Mathai et al. J. Fluid Mech., 2022, vol. 942, p. R4) compared with rigid foils. Here, we numerically investigate the effects of the in-plane stretching stiffness (or aeroelastic number),
$K_{\!S}$, the flapping frequency,
${\textit{St}}_c$, and the pitching amplitude,
$\theta _0$, on the propulsive performance of a compliant membrane undergoing combined heaving and pitching in uniform flow. Distinct optimal values of
$K_{\!S}$ are identified that respectively maximise thrust and efficiency: thrust can be increased by 200 %, and efficiency by 100 %, compared with the rigid case. Interestingly, these optima do not occur at resonance but at frequency ratios (flapping to natural) below unity, and this ratio increases with flapping frequency. Using a force decomposition based on the second invariant of the velocity gradient tensor
$Q$, which measures the relative strength between the rotation and deformation of fluid elements, we show that thrust primarily arises from
$Q$-induced and body-acceleration forces. The concave membrane surface can trap the leading-edge vortex (LEV) generated during the previous half-stroke, generating detrimental
$Q$-induced drag. However, moderate concave membrane deformation weakens this LEV and enhances body-acceleration-induced thrust. Thus, the optimal
$K_{\!S}$ for maximum thrust occurs below resonance, balancing beneficial deformation against excessive drag. Furthermore, by introducing the membrane’s deformation into a tangential angle at the leading edge and substituting it into an existing scaling law developed for rigid plates, we obtain predictive estimates for the thrust and power coefficients of the membrane. The good agreement confirms the validity of this approach and offers insights for performance prediction.