The image of the nagging woman being ducked as a scold is firmly
ensconced among popular images of women in the past, but the historical
phenomenon of prosecutions for scolding, though it has been briefly
touched on in many studies, has been the subject of only two substantial
contributions, those of David Underdown and Martin Ingram. Underdown
has maintained that from the 1560s there was increasing concern
with scolds, which he links with the rise in witchcraft prosecutions and
growing anxiety about domineering and unfaithful wives. Accepting the
notion of a ‘crisis of order’ in the decades around 1600, he
postulates as
an aspect of this a ‘crisis in gender relations’ which he attributes
to a
decline in neighbourliness and social harmony resulting from the spread
of capitalism. He bases his argument partly on literary sources, including
plays, sermons and popular pamphlets (though conceding that literary
evidence is not conclusive and that the misogynistic tradition in literature
is a long one) and partly on a somewhat impressionistic survey of court
records from around 1560 to around 1640. This period, he claims,
witnessed an intense preoccupation with women perceived as threatening
the patriarchal order, manifested by greater numbers of prosecutions of
scolds and other disorderly women than in the preceding and subsequent
periods, and by more severe punishments, notably the cucking-stool.
Women accused as scolds, he maintains, were usually poor, widows,
newcomers, social outcasts or ‘those lacking the protection of a
family’,
and were likely to vent their frustration on local notables as the nearest
symbols of authority. He suggests that both the prosecution of scolds and
their punishment by ducking were more common in towns and wood-pasture villages than in arable areas (such as that around Fordwich in
Kent, the borough we will be looking at); however, he admits that rural
records have survived less well than urban, and gives no quantified
evidence for the alleged lenience of the authorities in arable villages
towards ‘disorderly’ women.