We state as a fact, which we have received, on what we deem
undoubted authority, that the Puseyite party have bought up the
BRITISH CRITIC, which publication accordingly will from henceforth
be dedicated to the promulgation of their principles: The Record,
1 Jan. 1838
This article focuses on the Tractarian takeover and subsequent
control of the British Critic, a politically and theologically
conservative quarterly periodical, between 1838 and 1843. In
doing so it claims several justifications. Firstly, and primarily, it seeks to
demonstrate the importance of the Critic within first-generation Tractarianism
and therefore to rehabilitate an extensive periodical journalism
as a vital yet neglected source for historians of the movement. Though
various Tractarians such as Richard Hurrell Froude, John Henry
Newman, John Keble and Edward Bouverie Pusey had all written for the
British Magazine and William Sewell regularly for the Quarterly Review in
the early 1830s, it was the Critic which came to serve as the principal
medium for the movement's commentary. Historians' neglect of this
commentary, it is suggested, has had important consequences in terms of
our understanding of Tractarianism, for it has served to marginalise
certain aspects of the movement's early thought – in particular the social
criticism which was a consistent feature of the Critic's pages.