Relaxation data provide evidence that thermally generated defects with spin observed in thick, undoped hydrogenated amorphous silicon (a-Si:H) films can be stabilized with alternate structural configurations. Some quenched-in metastable spins, equilibrating further at a lower temperature, relax and become more resistant to annealing. Some of these defects take longer to anneal than any of the defects equilibrated only at the higher temperature. An obvious crossing of annealing data curves occurs on one of two differently prepared films. Crossover has important physical implications in deciding between defect models.
Such an observation necessitates the use of defect models with more complexity than variations based on two-level energy-configuration coordinate diagrams. Long annealing times may not be controlled simply by high energy barriers; the annealing of a spin may require many dispersive steps with smaller energy barriers. Models that stablize a spin by either hierarchically constrained defect configurations or the trapping of a mobile hydrogen in a distribution of sites can be used to explain this result. The fact that crossover is more obvious on the sample that has an oriented microstructure implicates film structure.