Article contents
Cultural evolution of genetic heritability
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 21 May 2021
Abstract
Behavioral genetics and cultural evolution have both revolutionized our understanding of human behavior – largely independent of each other. Here, we reconcile these two fields under a dual inheritance framework, offering a more nuanced understanding of the interaction between genes and culture. Going beyond typical analyses of gene–environment interactions, we describe the cultural dynamics that shape these interactions by shaping the environment and population structure. A cultural evolutionary approach can explain, for example, how factors such as rates of innovation and diffusion, density of cultural subgroups, and tolerance for behavioral diversity impact heritability estimates, thus yielding predictions for different social contexts. Moreover, when cumulative culture functionally overlaps with genes, genetic effects become masked, unmasked, or even reversed, and the causal effects of an identified gene become confounded with features of the cultural environment. The manner of confounding is specific to a particular society at a particular time, but a WEIRD (western, educated, industrialized, rich, and democratic) sampling problem obscures this boundedness. Cultural evolutionary dynamics are typically missing from models of gene-to-phenotype causality, hindering generalizability of genetic effects across societies and across time. We lay out a reconciled framework and use it to predict the ways in which heritability should differ between societies, between socioeconomic levels, and other groupings within some societies but not others, and over the life course. An integrated cultural evolutionary behavioral genetic approach cuts through the nature–nurture debate and helps resolve controversies in topics such as IQ.
Keywords
- Type
- Target Article
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press
References
- 30
- Cited by
Target article
Cultural evolution of genetic heritability
Related commentaries (29)
(Super-)cultural clustering explains gender differences too
A cultural evolutionary behavior genetics will need a more sophisticated conceptualization of cultural traits
Changes in heritability: Unpredictable and of limited use
Cultural dynamics add multiple layers of complexity to behavioural genetics
Cultural evolution and behavior genetic modeling: The long view of time
Cultural evolution may influence heritability by shaping assortative mating
Cultural evolution: The third component of mental illness heritability
Cultural evolutionary theory is not enough: Ambiguous culture, neglect of structure, and the absence of theory in behavior genetics
Culture and causal inference: The impact of cultural differences on the generalisability of findings from Mendelian randomisation studies
Culture is reducing genetic heritability and superseding genetic adaptation
Developmental noise is an overlooked contributor to innate variation in psychological traits
Differential application of cultural practices at the family and individual levels may alter heritability estimates
Evolving the blank slate
From the trajectory of heritability to the heritability of trajectories
Genetic solutions to cultural problems?
Going beyond heritability: Mechanisms of gene–culture coevolution
Heritability is a poor, if not unhelpful, measure of complex human behavioral processes
Hidden clusters beyond ethnic boundaries
Interpreting and reinterpreting heritability estimates in educational behavior genetics
Measuring heritability: Why bother?
Models of gene–culture evolution are incomplete without incorporating epigenetic effects
The dubious precision and utility of heritability estimates
The evolutionary dance between culture, genes, and everything in between
The implications of the cultural evolution of heritability for evolutionary psychology
The many geographical layers of culture
There is no such thing as culture-free intelligence
This time I mean it: The nature–nurture debate is over
Understanding cultural clusters: An ethnographic perspective
Unpackaging cultural variability in behavioral phenotypes
Author response
Integrating cultural evolution and behavioral genetics